[SPOILER ALERT]
It wasn’t as disappointing as I had feared it would be, but it wasn’t as awesome as I had hoped it would be.
Lost is one my top three favorite television shows, maybe even one of my top two; and were I to try to rate from a more objective standpoint all the TV shows from all time, I’m sure it would still make the top ten, maybe even the top five.
The first season remains my favorite. It focused more on the characters and their stories, while later seasons focused more on plot.
I liked the second season.
At first I had a tough time getting through the third season. Actually, the third season, probably more than any other, affected me on a personal level. I watched it during a very difficult time in my life, and it didn’t help much that I watched a show in which the characters in whom I had invested many hours of my life were constantly learning that a) they can’t trust anyone, and b) any decision they make will be the wrong one. The season finale, though, blew my mind.
I loved the fourth season. It’s my favorite season after the first. The story finally seemed to have some direction, and since at this point the producers declared that they would end the show after six seasons, it gave fans some hope that questions would be answered.
The fifth season was weird. It had its ups and downs, and time travel is always a tricky thing to play with.
And then there’s the sixth season. I have two big complaints about the sixth season. First, it made the smoke monster a main character. I always thought of the smoke monster as something the writers thought up under a time crunch and the influence of alcohol, an idea that seemed cool at first but looked stupid in hindsight. I always thought it was the worst thing about Lost. “Well, we’re stuck with it.” But it doesn’t mean you have to justify your mistake by giving it a bigger role.
Second, when they should be tying up loose ends and rounding off characters’ stories, the characters we’ve come to love after five seasons, they introduce a completely new plot line and a completely new character, and I never felt invested in either one. They reveal that the island is some sort of cork that keeps evil from pouring out into the world, and we’re just supposed to take their word for it. I never bought it. I mean, the world is a pretty crappy place with the island’s protection. They never showed us how Locke/Smoke Monster/Esau destroying the island would have doomed us all.
So I didn’t feel a lot of suspense about that, and while I understand that Jack’s sacrifice saved the world, I don’t feel like it did.
Which brings us to the final episode, about which I also have two big complaints. But first the positive: the final episode, in focusing on Jack’s character and growth, felt a lot like an episode from the first season. I love that he found his purpose, and I love that he gave himself up in such a Christlike way. Also, I think it was the great fear of all Lost fans that the show would fail to answer all the questions it raised. Well, of course it failed in that respect. It had to, and I’m not that upset about it, and if I’m not that upset about it, Lost must have done something right.
On to the negative. First, the twist. Yeah, it was cool, but it completely negated any kind of suspense or investment I had in the flash-sideways-es. I wanted to see how those loose ends would be tied up. Instead, I learned that those loose ends were mostly meaningless.
I was convinced that Desmond – who may or may not have become Jacob – was going to bring the characters from the flash-sideways-es over to the island, kind of a trans-dimensional kind of thing. So the characters that died on the island (Sayid, the Kwons) would be resurrected in a way, and these characters would save the island. Does it make sense? Maybe not, but it’s Lost. I think my ending was cooler.
Second, it really bothers me that that Ji Yeon Kwon, Jin and Sun’s daughter, remained an orphan at the end of the series. While Ji Yeon only made a couple of appearances (maybe just one that wasn’t a sonogram), her character was extremely important in Jin and Sun’s story. So what happens to her now? She gets raised by Sun’s Korean mob family? Yeah, that’s gonna turn out well. I wish that, while the submarine was going down, Sun would have said something like, “Our daughter!” and Jin, feeling awful about it, left her for the sake of their child. Even if Jin leaves Sun, no one will deny that they have reconciled and love each other deeply.
The final episode of Lost was sad, but it was positive. But leaving this poor girl without parents casts a dark shadow on an otherwise light picture. You could argue that such darkness is real, and I agree, but it doesn’t fit the tone that Lost ended on, the tone I believe Lost was going for.
Disagree? Then chime in. Convince me otherwise.
In conclusion, though, I liked the final episode more than I disliked it, if only by a little bit.
Farewell, Lost. You can and will never be replaced.
Favorite episode:
“The Moth” – Season 1, Episode 7
Best episode:
“Through the Looking Glass” – Season 3, Episode 22
A couple Lost moments that really got me:
“The Shape of Things to Come” – Season 4, Episode 9 – The last words Alex hears before she gets shot in the head are to the effect of, “Go ahead and kill her. She’s not even my daughter. She means nothing to me.”
“There’s No Place Like Home: Part 2″ – Season 4, Episode 13/14 – Sun loses it when she watches Jin’s ship explode.